RSU Taxes: The Withholding Gap and the Sell-or-Hold Decision

Jim Crider
Jim Crider, CFP®

November 16, 2026

The short version

Restricted stock units are taxed as wages on the day the shares are delivered, at their full market value, whether or not a single share is sold. Employers commonly withhold federal income tax on that value at a flat 22%, and for a household in the 32%, 35%, or 37% bracket that leaves a gap that comes due in April. In the worked example below, a couple with $192,000 of RSUs vesting in 2026 owes $54,580 of federal income tax on them, has $42,240 withheld, and is left $12,340 short. The gap is not a penalty and not a mistake by the employer. It is how the withholding rule works, and it can be measured before the first share vests.

Once the shares are delivered, the tax on them is fixed, and their basis is the value already taxed. Selling at vest adds little or no tax, and holding is the same decision as taking a cash bonus and buying the employer’s stock with it. We lean toward modeling the gap in the year’s tax projection and covering it on purpose, and toward selling at vest and keeping only what the financial plan can carry and the household would choose to own, after a conversation about the company and how much of the plan already rides on it.

How RSUs Are Taxed: Grant, Vest, and Sale

A restricted stock unit is a promise: stay employed through the vesting date (and, at some private companies, through a second condition described later), and the company delivers a share. Units that have not vested when employment ends are generally forfeited, though equity plans differ on retirement, death, and disability. Nothing is taxed when the grant is made, because nothing has been received. An employee generally cannot elect a different timing. The Section 83(b) election, which lets the holder of restricted stock choose to be taxed at grant, is not available for RSUs, because no stock changes hands until the units vest.

At vest. When the shares are delivered, their market value that day is ordinary wage income. It appears in Box 1 of the W-2 next to salary and bonus, and it is taxed at the household’s ordinary rates, from 10% to 37% in 2026. It is also subject to payroll taxes: Social Security tax of 6.2% up to the $184,500 wage base, Medicare tax of 1.45% on every dollar, and the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax on wages above $250,000 for a married couple ($200,000 for a single filer). The income arrives whether or not anything is sold, which is the feature that surprises people.

After vest. The value taxed at vest becomes the cost basis of the shares, and the holding period starts the day after. From there the shares are ordinary stock. If they are sold right away, there is little or no gain, because the sale price and the basis are nearly the same. If they are held, any later rise is a capital gain and any fall is a capital loss: short-term if the shares are held a year or less, and long-term, at rates of 0%, 15%, or 20%, if they are held for more than a year. Households with modified adjusted gross income above $250,000 (joint) can also owe the 3.8% net investment income tax on those gains, though never on the wage income at vest.

Performance units. Performance stock units follow the same rules with one more unknown. The number of shares delivered depends on how the company performs against its targets, so the income at vest can land anywhere from nothing to a multiple of the target grant, and the tax projection has to carry a range instead of a single figure.

That is the whole structure, and it is simpler than the rules for stock options. Our overview of stock compensation sets RSUs beside options and purchase plans. This article stays with two RSU questions: the withholding gap, and what to do with the shares.

The Withholding Gap: Why 22% Is Not Your Rate

An employer has to withhold income tax when RSUs vest, and the rules give it a shortcut. Stock delivered at vest is a supplemental wage, like a bonus, and an employer may withhold federal income tax on supplemental wages at a flat 22%, whatever the employee’s actual bracket. Once an employee’s supplemental wages for the year pass $1,000,000, the rate on the excess is a mandatory 37%. Employers commonly use the flat rate, and they usually collect it from the vesting shares themselves: either the company keeps back enough shares to cover the tax, or it sells enough of them on the employee’s behalf, a practice called sell to cover.

The flat rate is a withholding rule, not a tax rate. The tax actually owed on the shares depends on where they land in the household’s brackets, and for most people with meaningful RSU income that is above 22%. A married couple reaches the 24% bracket at $211,400 of taxable income in 2026, the 32% bracket at $403,550, the 35% bracket at $512,450, and the 37% bracket at $768,700. For a single filer the same brackets begin at $105,700, $201,775, $256,225, and $640,600. At the flat rate, every dollar of RSU income that lands above the 24% threshold is withheld at a lower rate than it is taxed.

Consider a hypothetical couple in the Dallas area, both 44. One spouse is a senior manager at a public company with a salary of $245,000 and RSUs that vest once a year, and in November 2026 the vest delivers $192,000 of stock. The other spouse earns $105,000. They take the standard deduction and have no other income, and Texas has no state income tax. The household is an illustration with 2026 federal law applied throughout. It is not a client and not a recommendation.

Without the RSUs, their taxable income would be $317,800, in the middle of the 24% bracket. The RSUs stack on top of that. The first $85,750 fills the rest of the 24% bracket and adds $20,580 of tax. The remaining $106,250 falls in the 32% bracket and adds $34,000. The federal income tax on the RSU income is $54,580, about 28.4% of its value. The employer withholds 22%, or $42,240. The difference, $12,340, is the withholding gap: tax that is owed, was never withheld, and comes due with the return unless the couple pays it in sooner.

Withholding at 22% leaves this couple $12,340 short on $192,000 of RSUs

Federal income tax owed on $192,000 of RSUs vesting in 2026, the amount withheld at vest, and the difference, for a hypothetical married couple with salaries of $245,000 and $105,000.

Federal income tax owed on the RSU income

$54,580

Withheld at the flat 22% rate

$42,240

The gap, due with the return unless paid in sooner

$12,340
A hypothetical married couple in Texas with the standard deduction and no other income, under 2026 law. Of the RSU income, $85,750 is taxed at 24% and $106,250 at 32%. Medicare taxes and the withholding on the couple’s salaries are left out. An illustration, not a recommendation. Our calculation.

Medicare taxes sit beside that gap, and nearly all of them are collected at the vest. Medicare tax of 1.45%, or $2,784, is withheld from the vest, and so is the 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax, another $1,728, because an employer must start withholding it once an employee’s own wages pass $200,000. The employer cannot see the other spouse’s paycheck, though, and the couple’s threshold is $250,000 of combined wages, so their return, on Form 8959, shows $495 more of that tax than the two employers withheld. That $495 would be there without the RSUs. It belongs in the projection all the same, and it brings the balance due on this couple’s return to $12,835, assuming their paycheck withholding exactly covers the tax on their salaries. (Real paycheck withholding rarely lands that exactly. With two earners it can fall well short unless both Forms W-4 account for the other job, which is one more reason to run the numbers instead of assuming them.) Social Security tax adds nothing over the year, because the salary alone is above the $184,500 wage base.

How large the gap is depends almost entirely on the bracket the shares land in. Each $100,000 of RSU income is withheld at $22,000. In the 24% bracket the tax on it is $24,000, a gap of $2,000. In the 32% bracket the gap is $10,000, in the 35% bracket $13,000, and in the 37% bracket $15,000, until supplemental wages pass $1,000,000 and the 37% withholding rate closes it.

Each $100,000 of RSU income can be under-withheld by as much as $15,000

Federal income tax owed on $100,000 of RSU income, less the $22,000 withheld at the flat 22% rate, by the bracket the income lands in. The copper bar is the top bracket.

In the 24% bracket

$2,000

In the 32% bracket

$10,000

In the 35% bracket

$13,000

In the 37% bracket

$15,000
Each bar is the bracket rate less the 22% supplemental withholding rate, applied to $100,000 of income that falls entirely within one bracket, under 2026 law. Once supplemental wages pass $1,000,000 in a year, employers must withhold at 37% on the excess and the gap closes. Our calculation.

The vest confirmation usually does not point to the gap. It shows shares withheld for taxes, which reads as though the tax has been handled. For an employee whose units vest every quarter, the same thing happens four times a year, a few thousand dollars at a time.

Closing the Gap Without a Penalty

A balance due in April is not itself a problem. The tax system charges for paying late only when too little was paid in during the year, and it measures that with safe harbors. A household owes no underpayment penalty if its withholding and timely estimated payments reach 90% of this year’s tax, or 110% of last year’s tax when last year’s adjusted gross income was above $150,000 (100% at or below that). The penalty, where it applies, is interest on the shortfall at the federal underpayment rate, which is 7% a year for the second half of 2026. Our article on estimated taxes and the safe harbor covers the rules in full.

For the couple in the example, this year’s total tax, with the Additional Medicare Tax included, is $118,676, and $105,841 is withheld. Ninety percent of this year’s tax is about $106,800, so they miss the first harbor by about $970. Suppose their 2025 return showed total tax of $104,000, because fewer shares vested that year. The second harbor is then 110% of that, or $114,400, and they are $8,559 short of it. Missing the nearer harbor would not cost much on these facts: the penalty is interest on the roughly $970 shortfall, not on the whole balance due, and comes to well under $100. A household whose paycheck withholding also runs short has more at stake.

Those two numbers describe two different jobs. Reaching the nearer harbor takes less than $1,000 of extra withholding, but that harbor is a moving target: it is measured against a tax bill that depends on the share price on the vest date and is not final until December 31, and a year-end bonus would move it. The prior-year harbor asks for $8,559 more and in exchange is a fixed number, known since the 2025 return was filed. Once withholding reaches $114,400, no underpayment penalty can apply to 2026, whatever the year’s income turns out to be, and the remaining $4,276 is due with the return on April 15, 2027.

The cleanest way to add the money is through a paycheck. Withholding is treated as if it had been paid evenly through the year, no matter when it actually came out, while an estimated payment counts only from the day it is made. In practice that means a new Form W-4 with an extra dollar amount per pay period in Step 4(c), set early in the year, when the vesting schedule is already known. At the projected share price, $8,559 over twenty-four semimonthly paychecks is about $357 each for this couple. The even-payment rule also allows a catch-up, because extra withholding in the last paychecks of the year covers the first quarter as well as the last. That is a repair for a year that went differently than planned, not something to rely on: it needs paychecks large enough to withhold from and a payroll change that takes effect in time. Some equity plans also let employees elect additional withholding on the vests themselves, and where that choice exists, it does the same job at the source.

Whatever is not paid in during the year has to exist in April. The couple’s shares are delivered net of withholding, and it is easy to treat what arrives as fully spendable. A plan that moves the amount still owed into a separate savings account on the day the shares are sold turns an April surprise into a transfer that was scheduled months earlier.

At Vest: Sell to Cover, Cost Basis, and the 1099-B That Leaves Basis Out

On the vest date the company’s equity plan delivers $192,000 of stock and immediately takes back part of it. Federal income tax at 22% is $42,240, and the two Medicare taxes are $4,512, so $46,752 of shares are withheld or sold and $145,248 of shares, about three quarters of the vest, land in the brokerage account. By November that spouse’s salary has passed the $184,500 wage base, so no Social Security tax comes out. Had the vest come early in the year, that tax would have come out of it and then stopped coming out of paychecks that much sooner, so the timing changes which check the tax comes from and not the year’s total.

Every delivered share has a cost basis equal to its value on its vest date, because that value has already been taxed as wages. This is the point that gets lost at tax time. The broker reports each sale on Form 1099-B, and for shares that came from equity pay the basis on that form is often blank, zero, or too low, because brokers need not report basis for RSU shares and, for awards granted after 2013, may not add the wage income to a basis they do report. A return prepared straight from that form taxes the same income twice: once as wages on the W-2 and again as a capital gain. The fix is to correct the basis on Form 8949, using the vest-date values that the equity plan’s supplemental statement or the vest confirmations show. Where the equity plan sells shares to cover taxes, those sales appear on the 1099-B too, and they need the same correction, even though their real gain or loss is a few dollars. Where the employer simply keeps shares back, there is no sale to report.

Each vest is its own tax lot, with its own basis and its own holding period. A household that holds shares from many vests and sells some of them can usually choose which lots to sell, and the choice matters: the highest-basis lots produce the least gain, and lots held for more than a year produce long-term gain. Lots that have fallen below their vest-date value can be sold first, at a loss that offsets gains on lots sold later. The wash sale rule described below can disallow that loss when another vest is near.

Sell or Hold: The Tax Is the Same Either Way

A common reason for holding vested shares is tax: the owner would like to wait a year for long-term rates. The reasoning does not fit how RSUs work. The tax on the vest is fixed on the vest date. It is the same whether the shares are sold that afternoon or held for a decade, and holding does not reduce it, defer it, or convert any of it to capital gain. What a year of holding earns is long-term treatment on whatever the stock gains after the vest, and what it risks is the full value of the shares.

A clearer way to see the decision is to set the stock aside. If the company had paid this couple a $192,000 cash bonus, withheld the same taxes, and deposited $145,248 in their account, would they use that cash to buy the company’s stock? If the answer is yes, holding the vested shares is the same position, reached without a trade. If the answer is no, or not that much, then holding the shares is a purchase they would not have made, and it happens by default every time units vest.

The numbers show the trade. Suppose the couple holds all $145,248 of delivered shares for a little more than a year. If the stock rises 30%, the shares gain $43,574, and the long-term gain is taxed at 15% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax, or $8,192, leaving them $35,382 better off than if they had sold at vest and held cash. If it rises 50%, the shares gain $72,624, the tax at the same rates is $13,653, and they finish $58,971 ahead. If the stock is unchanged, holding and selling come out the same. If it falls 30%, they are $43,574 behind, and if it falls 50%, $72,624 behind. The gain is taxed when it is realized, and the losses are shown before any tax benefit. The comparison is with cash, so it leaves out whatever the sale proceeds would have earned in a diversified portfolio over the same year.

A year of holding can leave this couple $58,971 ahead or $72,624 behind

How the couple finishes by holding their $145,248 of delivered shares for a little more than a year, compared with selling at vest and holding cash, at five share prices. Navy is ahead; copper is behind.

Stock up 50%

$58,971 ahead

Stock up 30%

$35,382 ahead

Stock unchanged

Even

Stock down 30%

$43,574 behind

Stock down 50%

$72,624 behind
Each gain is a long-term gain taxed at 15% plus the 3.8% net investment income tax. Losses are shown before any tax benefit, which is limited to offsetting capital gains and $3,000 of other income a year. The comparison leaves out whatever the sale proceeds would have earned elsewhere. Hypothetical results, not a forecast. Our calculation.

Two features of that picture deserve attention. The first is that the tax at vest does not follow the stock down. The couple owed $59,092 of federal income and Medicare tax on $192,000 of RSU income, and that bill stays the same if the shares they kept are later worth $72,624. A loss on the shares is a capital loss, which offsets capital gains and then only $3,000 of other income a year, so it comes nowhere near undoing wage income taxed at 32%. The second is that the upside case is not special to this stock. Any investment that rose 30% would have produced a gain, and a diversified one would have done so without tying the household’s savings to the same company that pays its salary.

That last point is the heart of it. Someone with RSUs already depends on one company for a paycheck, for a bonus, and for the unvested units still to come, whose value rises and falls with the share price. Vested shares held on top of that add a fourth exposure to the same source, and they add up quickly. If this couple kept every delivered share for four years at an unchanged price, they would hold $580,992 of company stock. If they also had $900,000 of other investments, the stock would be about 39% of the total. Our article on diversifying a concentrated stock position notes that most plans get uncomfortable well before a single stock reaches a third, and it covers what to do once a position has already built up with a low basis. RSUs offer what the holder of an old, low-basis position no longer has: a chance to diversify on the vest date, when the basis equals the price and selling costs little or nothing in tax.

The reasoning so far treats RSUs alone, and many people who have them also hold stock options. Every form of equity pay lands on the same tax return, so the pieces have to be planned together. One observation about risk is worth knowing here, and it comes from Daniel Zajac, a financial planner who writes on equity compensation: for someone who wants to turn part of their equity into cash, exercising and selling some options while keeping RSU shares can leave more after a price decline, because an option can lose all of its value in a fall that takes only part of a share’s. The trade-off is a smaller gain if the stock rises, and the exercise is usually taxable. For a household with RSUs alone, selling at vest is the natural place to start. Once options are in the picture, which to sell first deserves its own numbers.

Keeping shares can still be the right call. Someone who knows the company well, has room in the plan for the risk, and would buy the stock with cash is making an investment decision by keeping it. What the cash-bonus question guards against is the position nobody chose, built one vest at a time.

When Selling Is Not Simple

Selling at vest assumes the shares can be sold. Several rules can get in the way, and each is easier to plan around than to discover.

Trading windows and insiders. Many companies let employees trade only during open windows after earnings are released, and a vest can land in a closed one. Executives and others with regular access to inside information face tighter limits. A Rule 10b5-1 plan, adopted while the employee has no inside information (most company policies also require an open window), can schedule sales in advance so they run through closed windows automatically. The plan must wait out a cooling-off period before its first trade, 30 days for most employees and 90 to 120 days for officers and directors, so it has to be set up well before the vests it is meant to cover.

Wash sales. A vest is treated as an acquisition of shares. If a household sells company stock at a loss within 30 days before or after a vest, the wash sale rule disallows that loss to the extent of the shares that vested, and adds it to their basis. With quarterly vests, a large part of the calendar sits inside one of those windows. Our article on the wash sale rule explains the mechanics.

Private companies and the second trigger. At many private companies, RSUs vest only when two conditions are met: a period of service, and a liquidity event such as a public offering or a sale of the company. Until the second condition is met, nothing is delivered and nothing is taxed. When it is met, every unit whose service period has already run is delivered at once or soon after, and several years of vests arrive as wages in a single year. If this couple received $600,000 of stock that way instead of $192,000, the withholding at 22% would be $132,000 against a federal income tax of about $200,000 on it, a gap of about $68,000, and a lockup after a public offering can prevent selling any of the shares for months while the price moves. That is a year to model before the event, not after it.

A move to Texas. RSU income is generally taxed by the states where the work was done while the units were vesting, not only by the state of residence on the vest date. Someone who moves to Texas partway through a vesting period can still owe tax to the former state on part of each later vest, as our checklist for moving to Texas from California describes. Employers do not always withhold for the former state, which creates a second gap of the same kind.

Giving shares. For a household that gives to charity, vested shares held for more than a year and worth more than their basis are usually better to give than cash, because the gain is never taxed. That is a reason to keep particular lots for a particular purpose, which is different from keeping everything. Our article on charitable giving and donor-advised funds covers the mechanics.

A Year of RSUs, Planned

Put in order, the work for a household like this one is short. Early in the year, the vesting schedule goes into the tax projection at a reasonable share price, alongside both salaries, and the projection shows the gap and both safe harbor targets. The household then decides how to cover the gap: extra paycheck withholding, additional withholding on the vests if the equity plan allows it, or cash set aside from each vest for April. A standing instruction, written down, says what happens to the shares on each vest date. The projection is run again in late summer, when more of the year is known, and withholding is adjusted while there are still paychecks left to adjust.

Once a grant is in place, RSU income generally cannot be deferred or reshaped by the employee, but the income around it can. A large vest year is a year in which most deductions are worth more, so three decisions are each worth pricing in that year’s projection: the choice between Roth and traditional 401(k) contributions, a deferral through a nonqualified deferred compensation plan elected the year before, and charitable giving the household already intends. It is also a year in which other income is expensive to add, which affects the timing of a Roth conversion, the sale of an appreciated asset, or an option exercise. Our article on ISO exercises and the AMT shows how one of those decisions depends on the ordinary income around it.

How We Think About It

We lean toward treating RSU income as something to model, not something to estimate from the withholding. Each year’s vests go into the household’s tax projection with both spouses’ pay, and the projection gives three numbers: the tax the vests will actually add, what will be withheld, and the difference. From there we lean toward meeting a safe harbor through extra paycheck withholding, because withholding counts as paid evenly through the year and an estimated payment does not, and toward setting the rest aside in cash for April. Which harbor to aim for is a judgment about the year, made with the household’s CPA: the prior-year number is fixed and certain, and the current-year number can be smaller but is not final until December 31. The point of the exercise is an April bill that is known in advance and already funded.

We lean toward selling RSU shares at vest and keeping only what the plan can carry and the household would choose to own. The tax is the same either way, so the question is how much of the plan should depend on one company, and for most households with RSUs the paycheck and the unvested units already answer part of it. The amount worth keeping comes out of a conversation, the same one that applies to stock options: the company’s outlook, how much of the household’s net worth already sits in the stock, the unvested units and future grants still coming, any stock options or other company stock, and what the plan could lose without changing how the family lives. A household that decides to keep a meaningful position can hold it well, with lots chosen for giving and a written plan for trimming it over time.

This points the other way from our view of incentive stock options, where we lean, for the most part, toward holding what the plan can carry and selling the rest, and the reason is the tax code. Holding ISO shares can turn ordinary income into long-term gain, so there is a tax benefit to weigh against the risk. Holding RSU shares earns no such benefit on the value at vest. The case for holding that we take most seriously is this: someone with deep knowledge of the company and ample assets elsewhere may reasonably choose a concentrated investment, and the work then is sizing the position and planning around it.

Common Questions

How are RSUs taxed when they vest?

RSUs are taxed as ordinary wage income on the day the shares are delivered, at their full market value that day. The income appears on the W-2 with salary, and it is subject to federal income tax at the household’s ordinary rates, to Social Security tax up to the wage base, and to Medicare tax. No tax is due at grant, and the value taxed at vest becomes the cost basis of the shares.

Why do I owe tax in April when my employer already withheld on my RSUs?

Employers generally withhold federal income tax on RSUs at a flat 22%, which is lower than the rate most households with significant RSU income actually pay. A couple whose RSUs land in the 32% bracket is under-withheld by $10,000 on each $100,000 of vesting stock. The difference comes due with the tax return unless it is paid in during the year through extra withholding or estimated payments.

Should I sell RSUs as soon as they vest?

Selling at vest adds little or no tax beyond what the vest itself already triggered, because the basis of the shares equals the value already taxed as wages. We lean toward selling at vest and keeping only what the financial plan can carry and the household would choose to own, since holding adds investment risk in the same company that pays the salary and earns no tax benefit on the value at vest. The amount worth keeping comes out of a conversation about the company’s outlook, how much of the household’s net worth already sits in the stock, the unvested units and future grants still coming, any stock options or other company stock, and what the plan could lose without changing how the family lives.

Do I pay tax twice when I sell RSU shares?

Tax is paid twice only if the return uses the wrong basis. The Form 1099-B for shares from equity pay often shows a basis that is blank, zero, or too low, because brokers need not report it for RSU shares and may not add the wage income to a basis they do report. The correct basis is the vest-date value already reported on the W-2, and it is corrected on Form 8949.

Can I avoid an underpayment penalty in a year with large RSU income?

A household avoids the underpayment penalty by paying in, through withholding or timely estimated payments, at least 90% of this year’s tax or 100% of last year’s tax (110% when last year’s adjusted gross income was above $150,000). Extra paycheck withholding is the most flexible way to get there, because it is treated as paid evenly through the year even when it comes out of the last few paychecks. Any balance above the safe harbor is simply due with the return.

Does holding RSU shares for a year lower the tax?

Holding for more than a year lowers the tax only on gains that come after the vest, which are then long-term capital gains. The tax on the value at vest is fixed on the vest date and is the same whether the shares are sold that day or years later. If the shares fall after vest, the wage income is still taxed in full, and the loss is a capital loss with limited use.

Jim Crider

About the Author

Jim Crider, CFP®

Jim Crider, CFP®, is the founder of Intentional Living FP, a fee-only fiduciary wealth management firm in New Braunfels, Texas. He and the team work with business owners, real estate investors, and families approaching or in retirement, across Texas and nationwide. Read more about Jim.

You can verify Jim’s CFP® certification with CFP Board and see his NAPFA member profile.

This information is for educational purposes only and should not be considered specific financial, tax, or legal advice. Consult with a qualified professional before making financial decisions.

RSUs vesting this year?

We can run your household’s numbers: what this year’s vests will add in tax, what will be withheld, how to cover the difference, and how much company stock your plan can carry. The first conversation is simply a chance to see whether we are a good fit.

Fee-only fiduciary · No commissions · Always on your side of the table