The short version
The salary milestones most people have seen (six times pay by 50, eight times by 60) give two households with the same salary the same target, whatever they spend. A household that spends less needs a smaller portfolio and saves more on the way there; a household that spends more needs a larger one and saves less. For two hypothetical couples who each earn $240,000, the amount needed on a retirement date at 62 came to $1,257,000 for the couple who spends less and $1,820,000 for the one who spends more on the sketch for a plan that follows guardrails ($1,550,000 and $2,326,000 for a plan that never adjusts), and the amount each needed by 50 to stay on track, if each keeps saving what it saves now, came to $164,000 and $667,000 ($297,000 and $897,000), assuming returns of 10% a year while working and 7% in retirement, before 3% inflation. The guideline asks both for $1,440,000 by 50.
We lean toward a different check: start with the yearly spending the portfolio will have to cover after Social Security and any pension, run it through our published ballpark (about 4% of the portfolio for a plan that never adjusts, about 5.5% for one that follows guardrails) as a conversation starter, and price the bridge years before Social Security begins on their own. For anyone behind at 50 or 55, the choices that still move the answer are spending, saving more (including the catch-up contributions), the retirement date or part-time work, and the Social Security claiming age, and this article prices each one side by side.
This article draws on work published at Kitces.com, and we’d recommend reading it in full: Michael Kitces’s 2017 article on the real reason big savers retire early, which is where the point that saving counts twice, and its reverse, comes from, and which makes that point the way our example does, by comparing savers on the same income; his 2012 article on whether saving a set percentage of income is bad retirement advice, which is where the lesson that saving often peaks late in a career comes from; and Derek Tharp’s 2017 guest post on safe savings rates with real-world income growth, which supplies the research on how pay actually grows over a career. The couples, the figures, and the check itself are our own.
If you are 50, 55, or 60, the question “am I on track?” usually arrives with a number attached: a multiple of your salary that someone said you should have saved by now. The number is easy to find and easy to compare against, and for a household with no plan at all it is a reasonable nudge. But it measures the wrong thing. How much you need depends on what your life will cost, not on what you earn, and two households on the same salary can be hundreds of thousands of dollars apart. This article explains where the salary milestones come from, why they mislead, the spending-based check we lean toward instead, and what still moves the answer if you are starting late.
The Milestones Most People Have Seen
The best-known version comes from one large fund company’s widely quoted guideline: save at least one times your salary by 30, three times by 40, six times by 50, eight times by 60, and ten times by 67. The current edition, published September 25, 2026, names no milestone for 55. On a combined salary of $240,000, the milestones work out to $1,440,000 at 50, $1,920,000 at 60, and $2,400,000 at 67.
The guideline is built carefully, and its assumptions are worth knowing because they are where it breaks. It assumes saving 15% of pay every year from age 25, with any employer match counted in that 15%, pay that rises 1.5% a year faster than inflation, retirement at 67 with Social Security claimed the same year, a plan that runs to 93, no pension, and savings that replace 45% of pre-retirement income. It is set to hold up in poor markets, at a 90% confidence level in its market simulations. The same guideline says retiring at 65 takes about 12 times salary and retiring at 70 about 8 times, which on $240,000 is $2,880,000 and $1,920,000.
Look closely at the 45%. For a couple earning $240,000, the guideline’s default assumes savings will have to supply $108,000 a year in retirement, every year. That one assumption carries most of the weight. The same page offers a lower multiple for a household that expects to spend less in retirement and a higher one for a household that expects to spend more, but each is still a multiple of pay, not a figure built from what the household actually spends.
Why a Multiple of Salary Misleads
A salary multiple is a shortcut for a question it never asks: what will this household’s life cost once the paychecks stop? Five things go wrong when the shortcut stands in for the question.
It grows with pay, not with spending. Two couples who both earn $240,000 get the same targets from the guideline, $1,440,000 at 50 and $1,920,000 at 60. If one spends $147,000 a year and the other $171,000, those targets are wrong for at least one of them, and usually for both. A raise moves every milestone up even when the household’s spending stays where it was, and a household that keeps spending flat while its pay rises looks further behind each year when it is actually pulling ahead.
Saving counts twice. We put it this way in our own planning: “Saving more is double-counted in the client’s favor: it adds to the portfolio and shrinks the retirement target at the same time, because a lower-spending lifestyle costs less to replace.” The reverse holds as well: “a steady savings percentage against a fast-rising lifestyle can leave a diligent saver further from retirement at 55 than at 25, because the target grows faster than the portfolio.” A salary multiple sees neither half. It credits a dollar saved once, and it never notices that the dollar not spent also lowers the finish line.
Social Security replaces a different share of every income. The benefit formula is progressive, and it stops counting wages above the taxable maximum ($184,500 in 2026). So Social Security covers a larger share of a modest lifestyle than of an expensive one, and a larger share of a $240,000 income than of a $500,000 one. A multiple that is the same at every income cannot reflect that. A couple whose benefits will cover most of their spending needs far less saved than the multiple says; a high earner whose benefits will cover a small part of it can need more.
It cannot see the bridge. The guideline assumes Social Security begins the year work ends. Many people retire first and claim later, and some have a pension that starts at a set age. The years in between are paid entirely from savings, and they can cost far more than a multiple built for a 67-year-old retiree suggests. In the example below, five bridge years add about half a million dollars to what each couple needs.
It assumes a straight line. A milestone at 50 implies that saving happens evenly across a career. It rarely does. The earnings research Derek Tharp drew on found that real pay tends to rise fastest in the first decade or two of a career and then level off or slip, often a decade or more before retirement. The costs of raising a family, meanwhile, usually fall away in the 50s, so the room to save tends to arrive late. In our planning, “Back-loaded savings is the expected shape of a high-earnings-growth plan, not evidence of being behind; peak savings years belong in the final stretch before retirement.” A household below a straight line at 50 may simply be on that shape. Our article on the five years before retirement looks at why saving so often peaks in that stretch.
None of this makes the salary milestones useless. They are an honest attempt to give people a number, and they are a fair alarm for a household that has saved nothing. They are just the wrong ruler for a household that wants to know where it actually stands.
The Check We Lean Toward: Start With Spending
We lean toward measuring progress at 50, 55, and 60 against the yearly spending your portfolio will have to cover after Social Security and any pension, sketched with our published ballpark (about 4% of the portfolio for a plan that never adjusts, about 5.5% for one that follows guardrails) as a conversation starter; salary multiples by age are worth knowing mainly to see why they mislead, because they grow with your pay rather than with what your household actually spends.
The check fits in one line. The amount needed on the retirement date is the yearly gap (retirement spending, plus the income tax still owed on withdrawals, minus Social Security and any pension) divided by the ballpark rate, plus a separate reserve for any bridge years. Dividing by about 5.5% is the same as multiplying by about 18, and dividing by 4% the same as multiplying by 25. Four steps build it.
Step 1: Build the retirement spending figure from today’s spending. We lean toward building the retirement spending figure from what the household spends today, not from what it earns: take out the costs that end by the retirement date (a mortgage that will be paid off, children’s costs, the commute), add the costs that begin (health coverage before Medicare, more travel in the early, active years), and keep the income tax still owed in retirement. We look hardest at why spending rose in the middle years, because costs that grew with the family’s needs usually end, while lifestyle that grew with income usually comes along into retirement. A larger grocery bill for a family of six, school costs, and the third car for a teenage driver are needs that leave with the children. A bigger house, a second home, and a habit of upgrading the car every few years are lifestyle, and they tend to stay. Retirement changes some costs in both directions: more free time often means more travel in the first years, while no daily commute can mean less driving and one fewer car. The figure to aim for is the spending you actually expect, including the way spending tends to change as retirement goes on; research finds that, on average, it drifts down in real terms over the decades, as our article on the retirement spending smile explains, so a level figure like the ones in our example leaves some margin. Our article on lifestyle creep covers how spending drifts upward with income before retirement.
Step 2: Subtract Social Security and any pension. Use the benefit at the age you expect to claim, in today’s dollars, from your own statement at ssa.gov. The statement assumes you keep earning about what you earn now until you claim, so stopping work years earlier can mean a somewhat smaller benefit than it shows. For a married couple, it is the combined benefit, and the claiming ages matter: for anyone born in 1960 or later, a benefit on your own work record pays 70% of the full benefit at 67 if claimed at 62, and 124% if you wait to 70 (a spousal benefit is cut more at 62 and stops growing at 67). A pension that starts at a set age counts here from that age on.
Step 3: Run the yearly gap through the ballpark. Divide the gap that is left (including the income tax on the withdrawals) by about 5.5% for a plan that will follow guardrails, or about 4% for one that never adjusts. A $50,000 gap, for example, sketches to about $909,000 at 5.5% and about $1,250,000 at 4%. That sketch starts a conversation; it is not a rule of thumb and never a plan. The higher rate is bought with a willingness to adjust: spending and giving come down for a while in a bad decade and go up in a good one, on lines agreed in advance. Those lines are built on the risk-based guardrails research Derek Tharp and Justin Fitzpatrick published at Kitces.com. Our article on the 4% rule covers the research behind the lower rate. The 4% figure comes from the historical record of 30-year retirements, and our guardrails article charts every 30-year retirement that began between 1871 and 1993; a couple retiring at 62 and planning into their early 90s sits close to that length. A longer retirement leaves more years for a bad stretch of markets to land in, and a shorter one leaves fewer, which is why a withdrawal rate that strains a portfolio at 65 can be modest at 90. The longer the plan we agree on with the household, the lower the starting point it supports, or the more room for adjustments we build in, and the shorter, the more it can support; once that length is set, we lean toward starting where the plan puts spending and letting the guardrails do their work, as our article on how long a retirement plan should last explains.
How much room to adjust the plan needs is something we lean toward settling with the household before retirement starts, not in the middle of a bad year. Using the core and adaptive split Michael Kitces has described, we sort the budget into spending the plan will not cut and spending that can flex (often the size of a trip, not whether it happens); the larger the part that will not be cut, the more conservatively spending starts. We lean toward translating the guardrails into dollars before anything happens, so that a falling market brings a known number rather than a guess. On the settings, we lean toward starting in the underspending zone, raising spending fully when the plan clearly allows it, and cutting in small steps (often a few percent of spending), with warning beforehand; a cut holds until the plan earns a raise. A long decline can bring a second small cut, or a third; in the hardest historical periods, total cuts can be large under any approach. Our article on retirement spending guardrails explains what starting in the underspending zone means and walks through the settings and the stress tests.
Step 4: Price the bridge years on their own. When the retirement date comes before Social Security or a pension begins, we lean toward pricing those bridge years on their own: the portfolio, or a reserve set aside for them, pays the full cost of each year until that income starts, and the reserve sits on top of the long-term sketch, not inside it. In practice, that means taking, for each bridge year, how much more the portfolio has to pay that year than it will once the benefit starts, taxes included, and discounting each later year back to the retirement date. Health coverage before Medicare at 65 usually belongs here, because it is often the largest cost that starts and then stops. Our articles on health insurance before Medicare and on reaching retirement money before 59½ cover the rules that shape those years.
Then turn the number into a checkpoint. The steps give the amount needed on the retirement date. To know where you should be today, work backward: what you have now, grown to the retirement date, plus what you will keep saving between now and then, also grown, should reach the number. The checkpoint for any age is the balance that does that. It depends on how much you will keep saving, which is why two households with the same number at retirement can need very different amounts at 50.
Two Couples, One Salary
Here is the check at work for two hypothetical couples. Both are 50, and both earn $240,000 together, $145,000 for one spouse and $95,000 for the other. Both plan to retire at 62 and claim Social Security at 67, when their combined benefit will be $78,000 a year in today’s dollars, and both expect health coverage before Medicare to cost $24,000 a year for the two of them from 62 to 64. They pay federal tax at 2026 rates and no state income tax, as in Texas, and they save first into their two 401(k)s, pre-tax. The only difference between them is what they spend.
What the numbers rest on. Every figure is in today’s dollars, with inflation assumed at 3% a year, so pay, spending, Social Security, the contribution limits, and the tax brackets all rise with inflation, and pay gets no raise beyond that. Investments earn 10% a year while the couples work and 7% a year once they retire. Those are returns before inflation; because every figure is restated in today’s dollars, they work out to about 6.8% and 3.9% a year after inflation. These are the assumptions we use for illustrations, not a forecast. Each couple keeps saving what it saves now, at the end of every year until 62, and what it has already saved and each new dollar grow at the same rate. The number needed at 62 is the long-term withdrawal divided by about 5.5% (or about 4% for a plan that never adjusts), plus the bridge reserve: each bridge year’s extra withdrawal, taken at the start of the year and discounted at the 7% retirement return. Every withdrawal is taxed as ordinary income, and spending holds level for life. The temporary deduction for people 65 and older ends after 2028, long before either couple turns 65, so it is left out. One simplification flatters the numbers a little: the example lets the income levels at which Social Security becomes taxable rise with inflation, as the brackets do. The law fixes those levels in dollars and never raises them, so a little more of each benefit is taxed every year, and the tax on the withdrawals would run somewhat higher over time, most of all for the Garzas.
The Garzas spend $147,000 a year. After $18,360 of payroll tax and about $24,000 of federal income tax, that leaves $50,600 a year to save, 21.1% of their pay. The Whitfields spend $171,000. Their income tax is higher, about $30,800, because less of their pay goes into pre-tax savings, and they save $19,900 a year, 8.3% of their pay. A $24,000 difference in spending became a $30,700 difference in saving, because every pre-tax dollar the Garzas save also lowers their tax bill.
Then Step 1. Both couples expect their mortgage ($24,000 a year), their children’s costs ($12,000), and their work costs, such as the commute, a second car, and lunches ($5,000), to end by 62, and both plan to travel more in the early years ($10,000 more). That takes the Garzas from $147,000 today to $116,000 a year in retirement and the Whitfields from $171,000 to $140,000. To keep the example simple, both hold that spending level for life.
Steps 2 and 3. Once Social Security starts, the Garzas’ portfolio has to supply $38,000 of spending a year plus about $5,000 of federal income tax on the withdrawals, a long-term withdrawal of about $43,000. At 5.5%, that sketches to $782,000; at 4%, to $1,075,000. The Whitfields need $62,000 a year plus about $12,200 of tax, a long-term withdrawal of about $74,200, which sketches to $1,349,000 at 5.5% and $1,855,000 at 4%.
Step 4 is the bridge, and it is large for both. From 62 to 64 the Garzas’ portfolio pays the whole $140,000 of spending (their $116,000 plus $24,000 of health coverage), plus about $16,800 of tax: about $156,800 a year, or $113,800 more than it will once Social Security starts. At 65 and 66, with Medicare in place (its premiums and other health costs are assumed to sit inside the $116,000), it pays about $126,400 a year, $83,400 more than later. Discounted back to 62 at the 7% retirement return, before 3% inflation (about 3.9% a year in today’s dollars), those five years come to a bridge reserve of about $475,000. The Whitfields’ bridge works out almost the same, about $471,000, because the bridge mostly replaces the same $78,000 of Social Security and the same health coverage. The bridge does not change with the sketch.
Same $240,000 salary, very different numbers
Amount needed on a retirement date at 62, two hypothetical couples, 2026 dollars
Navy: a plan that follows guardrails (about 5.5%). Copper: the extra needed if the plan never adjusts (about 4%). Gold: the salary guideline.
The Garzas, spending $147,000 a year today: $1,257,000 with guardrails, $1,550,000 if the plan never adjusts
The Whitfields, spending $171,000 a year today: $1,820,000 with guardrails, $2,326,000 if the plan never adjusts
Salary guideline, 10 times pay by 67: $2,400,000
So on the retirement date, the Garzas need about $1,257,000 on the guardrails sketch and about $1,550,000 if their plan will never adjust. The Whitfields need about $1,820,000 and $2,326,000. Same salary, and the gap between their numbers is $563,000 on the guardrails sketch and $776,000 on the other. The guideline asks both for ten times salary, $2,400,000, by 67, and more for a retirement at 62.
This is saving counting twice, in dollars. The Whitfields’ extra $24,000 of spending today costs them $30,700 of saving every year they work, and it follows them into retirement as $24,000 more spending a year, which with tax takes about $31,200 more a year out of the portfolio. Neither couple’s salary says anything about that.
Now the checkpoints. Working back from the number at 62, and assuming each couple keeps saving what it saves now, with growth of 10% a year and 3% inflation (an assumption for this illustration, not a forecast), here is where each couple would need to be at 50, 55, and 60 to stay on track.
The salary guideline asks far too much of the couple who spends less
Amount needed at each age to stay on track for retiring at 62, against the salary guideline, 2026 dollars
Navy: a plan that follows guardrails (about 5.5%). Copper: the extra needed if the plan never adjusts (about 4%). Gold: the salary guideline.
At 50
The Garzas: $164,000 with guardrails, $297,000 if the plan never adjusts
The Whitfields: $667,000 with guardrails, $897,000 if the plan never adjusts
Salary guideline, 6 times pay: $1,440,000
At 55
The Garzas: $518,000 with guardrails, $703,000 if the plan never adjusts
The Whitfields: $1,041,000 with guardrails, $1,360,000 if the plan never adjusts
Salary guideline: no figure published for 55
At 60
The Garzas: $1,010,000 with guardrails, $1,267,000 if the plan never adjusts
The Whitfields: $1,560,000 with guardrails, $2,003,000 if the plan never adjusts
Salary guideline, 8 times pay: $1,920,000
At 50, the Garzas need $164,000 on the guardrails sketch ($297,000 if the plan never adjusts) and the Whitfields $667,000 ($897,000); the guideline says $1,440,000 for both. At 55, the Garzas need $518,000 ($703,000) and the Whitfields $1,041,000 ($1,360,000), and the guideline has no figure. At 60, the Garzas need $1,010,000 ($1,267,000) and the Whitfields $1,560,000 ($2,003,000); the guideline says $1,920,000 for both.
The guideline is too high for the Garzas at 50 and at 60, by more than a million dollars at 50. For the Whitfields it is too high on the guardrails sketch at both ages, but if their plan will never adjust, $1,920,000 at 60 would leave them $83,000 short of their own checkpoint. Suppose each couple has $900,000 at 50. The guideline tells both they are $540,000 behind. The spending check tells a different story: if they keep saving as they do now, the Garzas reach about $2,876,000 by 62, far more than they need on either sketch, while the Whitfields reach about $2,332,000, $512,000 more than their guardrails number and almost exactly the number for a plan that never adjusts.
The Garzas’ low checkpoint at 50 is not permission to stop saving. It is low because their $50,600 a year, for twelve more years, is expected to do most of the work; if they cut their saving, the checkpoint rises. The growth assumption matters too. On the sketch for a plan that never adjusts, at 8% a year while working instead of 10%, the Garzas would need $425,000 at 50 and the Whitfields $1,139,000; at 9%, $357,000 and $1,011,000; at 11%, $245,000 and $796,000. The order never changes: the household that spends less needs less, at every age and every return.
Behind at 50 or 55: What Each Choice Is Worth
Plenty of people reach 50 with less than they hoped, often for good reasons: a late start after paying for school, years of raising children on one income, a business that took every dollar before it paid any back, a divorce, or a parent who needed help. For a late starter, the check above does the same job it does for anyone. It turns “behind” into a number, and it shows which choices still move that number.
Suppose the Whitfields reach 55 with $700,000. The assumptions are the same as above: the $700,000 and every new dollar grow 10% a year before 3% inflation until 62 (about 6.8% a year in today’s dollars), they keep saving $19,900 a year, and the catch-ups count only in the catch-up row below. Their checkpoint at 55 is $1,041,000 on the guardrails sketch, so they are $341,000 behind ($660,000 behind a checkpoint of $1,360,000 if their plan will never adjust). If nothing changes and they keep saving $19,900 a year, they reach 60 with about $1,086,000, against a checkpoint of $1,560,000 ($2,003,000): $474,000 behind ($917,000). At 62 they would have about $1,280,000 against the $1,820,000 they need, a shortfall of about $540,000 (about $1,046,000 against $2,326,000 if the plan never adjusts). Four kinds of choices can close it: spending, saving more, the retirement date, and the Social Security claiming age. Here is what each is worth on its own, priced against the same shortfall.
No single choice closes the Whitfields’ whole gap on its own
The Whitfields at 55 with $700,000: how much of their shortfall at 62 each choice closes on its own, 2026 dollars
Navy: with guardrails (about 5.5%). Copper: the extra if the plan never adjusts (about 4%). The top bar is the shortfall itself; each bar below it is what one choice closes.
The shortfall at 62: $540,000 with guardrails, $1,046,000 if the plan never adjusts
Spend $10,000 a year less, now and in retirement: $349,000 with guardrails, $439,000 if the plan never adjusts
Save the amount of both catch-ups on top: $151,000 on either sketch
Retire at 64 instead of 62: $424,000 on either sketch
Work part time ($40,000 a year) from 62 to 64: $104,000 on either sketch
Both claim Social Security at 70 instead of 67: $63,000 with guardrails, $222,000 if the plan never adjusts
Spending. Spending $10,000 a year less, starting now and carried into retirement, closes about $349,000 of the gap on the guardrails sketch ($439,000 if the plan never adjusts): the pre-tax saving it frees grows for seven years, and the lower spending shrinks the number needed. This is saving counting twice again. A cut does not have to be permanent to help, but the part that lowers the number needed only counts if the lower spending carries into retirement.
The catch-up contributions. The tax code lets savers 50 and older put more into workplace plans. In 2026 the base limit on employee deferrals to a 401(k), 403(b), or governmental 457(b) is $24,500, and savers 50 and older can add an $8,000 catch-up, or $11,250 for those who reach 60, 61, 62, or 63 during the year. In 2027 those limits rise to $25,500, $8,500, and $11,750. Since 2026, a saver whose prior-year Social Security wages from the employer sponsoring the plan exceeded $150,000 must make the age-based catch-up to a 401(k), 403(b), or governmental 457(b) as a Roth contribution; for 2027 catch-ups, the line is $155,000 of 2026 wages. Our article on the Roth catch-up rule explains who it reaches. IRAs allow $7,500 plus a $1,100 catch-up in 2026 and 2027, and a health savings account allows an extra $1,000 from 55 for anyone eligible to contribute to one. If the Whitfields save the amount of both catch-ups on top of what they save now ($16,000 a year, then $22,500 at 60 and 61), it closes about $151,000 of the gap on either sketch. They would not need the catch-up room to do it: at $19,900 a year between them, they are well under their two base limits, and the catch-ups add room only for a saver who has already reached the base limit. Saved pre-tax, the first $16,000 costs them only about $12,500 of take-home pay a year. A business owner with a side plan has more room still, as our article on saving with a day job and a side business explains.
The retirement date, or part-time work. Working to 64 instead of 62 closes about $424,000 on either sketch, measured on the later date in today’s dollars: two more years of saving, two more years of growth on everything already saved, and two fewer bridge years to fund. A single extra year closes about $206,000. Earning $40,000 a year part time for the three years from 62 to 64, with the retirement date unchanged, closes about $104,000, because it shrinks the bridge without adding saving. Research points the same way. Gila Bronshtein, Jason Scott, John Shoven, and Sita Slavov found in a 2018 National Bureau of Economic Research working paper that delaying retirement by three to six months raised a household’s sustainable standard of living about as much as saving one more percentage point of pay for 30 years, and that saving more late in a career moved it even less. Their paper assumes Social Security starts when work stops, so part of what a later date bought there was a later claim.
Whether the work is enjoyable changes that trade. Matching what two more working years are worth to the Whitfields would take about $49,300 more saving every year from 55 to 62, on top of the $19,900 they already save, much of it out of what they spend now. In a separate 2017 article at Kitces.com, on three types of retirement, Michael Kitces made a related point: full-time leisure often turns out less satisfying than people expect, and scaled-back work can be a retirement in its own right. When the work is something the household enjoys, we lean toward weighing a later date or part-time work side by side with a higher savings rate, rather than assuming the earliest possible exit is the goal.
The Social Security claiming age. Claiming at 70 instead of 67 raises the Whitfields’ combined benefit from $78,000 to about $96,700 a year for life, with a larger benefit for whichever spouse survives, but it stretches the bridge from five years to eight. The larger lifelong benefit outweighs the longer bridge on both sketches: delaying closes about $63,000 of the gap on the guardrails sketch and about $222,000 if the plan will never adjust. Claiming at 62 shortens the bridge to the three years before Medicare but cuts the benefit to about $54,600 a year for life, so it adds to the number needed on both sketches: about $72,000 with guardrails and about $241,000 if the plan will never adjust. The example has both spouses claim at the same age to keep it simple; for a couple with unequal benefits, the survivor benefit often argues for the higher earner waiting longer. The amount needed on one date is only part of the claiming decision, which also turns on health, the survivor benefit, taxes, and how comfortable the household is spending from a portfolio. Our articles on when to claim Social Security and on claiming strategies for married couples work through it.
Two choices together go a long way: spending $10,000 a year less and retiring at 64 closes about $815,000 on the guardrails sketch, more than the whole $540,000 shortfall, and about $905,000 of the $1,046,000 if the plan never adjusts. We do not put the choices in a fixed order, because the right order depends on the household: on whether the work is still enjoyable, on which spending matters to them and which does not, and on their health and how Social Security fits the rest of the plan. A couple who loves their work may find two more years easy; a couple whose bodies are telling them it is time may find spending changes far easier than another winter of commuting.
Compounding has three inputs: time, the amount saved, and the rate of growth. At 25, time is the one a saver controls most. At 55, it is the one left that can barely be moved, except by moving the retirement date, and the rate of growth depends mostly on markets. The amount saved still matters, but less with each year that passes, because each dollar has fewer years to grow.
$10,000 more a year is worth less every year you wait
Value at 62 of saving $10,000 more each year, by the age you start, 2026 dollars
Starting at 50
Starting at 55
Starting at 60
Saving $10,000 more a year starting at 50 adds about $176,800 by 62, in today’s dollars, at the same 10% growth and 3% inflation. Starting at 55, it adds about $86,000; starting at 60, about $20,700. One more year of work, by contrast, closed about $206,000 of the shortfall the Whitfields face at 62. That is the arithmetic behind the research on working longer, and it is why a late start is usually best met with more than one choice at once.
How We Think About It
The check above is the one we lean toward. If we were to offer a rule of thumb, it would be about spending, not salary: the yearly spending the portfolio will have to fund, after Social Security and any pension and adjusted for how spending tends to change through retirement, times roughly 18 for a plan that follows guardrails or 25 for one that never adjusts. By the time a household has done the work to get that spending figure right, it is no longer using a rule of thumb; it is doing the work of planning. The income tax on the withdrawals goes into that yearly figure before it is multiplied, and a reserve for any bridge years goes on top, as in the four steps above.
In our planning, the number is never the place we start. Every plan begins with what the money is for, written down as a Statement of Financial Purpose, and then maps the household’s actual spending and giving, year by year, against its actual income: Social Security on the household’s own claiming choices, any pension, rental or business income, and withdrawals from each kind of account, each taxed the way it would actually be taxed. How much is enough comes out of that projection rather than going into it. Our article on how much you need to retire walks through what goes into it. The four steps above are what we use before any of that modeling exists, when someone wants to know roughly where they stand.
Most of the conversation happens in Step 1, because the spending figure drives everything after it, and because the honest version of it takes some thought: which costs leave with the children, which stay with the lifestyle, and which begin the day work stops. None of this is an argument for spending less. The goal is not to spend less; it is to spend right, and a spending figure built honestly is what lets a household spend and give with confidence once it retires. The bridge gets the same care in Step 4, because keeping it separate keeps the long-term sketch honest and makes the trade-offs visible: a later retirement date, part-time work, or a different claiming age each change the bridge in dollars a household can see.
We encourage a high savings rate early, because a dollar saved at 30 has decades more to compound than one saved at 55; the dollar amounts still usually peak in the last ten or fifteen years of work, because income is at or near its high point and the costs of raising children have usually ended. Both are true for most households, which is why being below a straight-line path at 50 is not, on its own, a sign of being behind. That said, we lean against counting on a surge of saving later. We have seen many households reach the empty-nest years and, as they get older, tire of putting off the bigger purchases, so the extra saving never arrives. Money used for purposeful living and giving is not the mistake; assuming you will save a lot later is the risk.
The check has limits, and we would rather name them than hide them. The ballpark rates are a sketch, not a plan, and the 5.5% figure assumes a household that will actually adjust. The tax line in the examples assumes every withdrawal is taxed as ordinary income; Roth and taxable accounts would lower it, and a large pre-tax balance can raise it later through required distributions. Health costs late in life, a longer retirement than planned, and an inheritance or a business sale sit outside the sketch, and any one of them can move the number a long way. And a checkpoint at 50 rests on a household continuing to save what it saves now, which is a promise worth keeping in view. Those are reasons to build the real plan, not reasons to go back to a salary multiple.
Common Questions
How much should I have saved for retirement by 50?
You need enough that what you have now, plus what you will keep saving, grows into the amount your retirement spending will require, and that depends far more on what you spend than on what you earn. The widely quoted guideline of six times salary by 50 gives every household on the same salary the same answer. In our example, assuming returns of 10% a year while working and 7% in retirement, before 3% inflation, two couples who each earn $240,000 and keep saving what they save now needed $164,000 and $667,000 at 50 to stay on track for retiring at 62 on the guardrails sketch ($297,000 and $897,000 for a plan that never adjusts), against $1,440,000 from the guideline. Start with your retirement spending and the income tax still owed on it, subtract Social Security and any pension, divide the gap by about 5.5% (or about 4% if the plan will never adjust) for a rough sketch, add a reserve for any years before Social Security begins, and work back to today.
How much should I have saved by 55?
The salary guideline most people quote does not give a figure for 55, and the spending check gives a figure that is personal. For the two couples in our example, both earning $240,000 and retiring at 62, and assuming returns of 10% a year while working and 7% in retirement, before 3% inflation, the checkpoint at 55 was $518,000 for the couple spending $147,000 a year and $1,041,000 for the couple spending $171,000, on the guardrails sketch. For a plan that never adjusts, it was $703,000 and $1,360,000. The difference comes from spending: it sets both how much each couple saves and how much each will need.
How much should I have saved by 60?
At 60, the answer is most of the amount needed on the retirement date, because only a few years of saving and growth are left. The guideline says eight times salary, $1,920,000 on a $240,000 salary. Assuming returns of 10% a year while working and 7% in retirement, before 3% inflation, our two example couples needed $1,010,000 and $1,560,000 at 60 on the guardrails sketch, and $1,267,000 and $2,003,000 for a plan that never adjusts, so on the sketch for a plan that never adjusts, the guideline was too high for one and too low for the other. If retirement comes before Social Security begins, the bridge years can be a large piece of the number: about $475,000 for one couple and $471,000 for the other in our example.
Is 10 times my salary enough to retire?
Ten times salary can be far too much or not enough, because it is a multiple of pay set for retiring at 67, not a figure built from what you spend, how much Social Security or a pension will cover, or when you actually retire. The guideline behind it assumes retirement and a Social Security claim at 67, and savings that replace 45% of pre-retirement income: $108,000 a year on a $240,000 salary. Our two example couples both earned $240,000; to retire at 62, one needed $1,257,000 on the guardrails sketch and the other $1,820,000 ($1,550,000 and $2,326,000 for a plan that never adjusts). A household that spends heavily for its income, or whose benefits will cover little of its spending, can need more than ten times, and retiring earlier raises the number for the same household.
What should I do if I’m behind on retirement savings at 50 or 55?
Start by measuring “behind” against your own spending, because a household that looks behind on a salary multiple can be on track, and the reverse. If there is a real gap, four kinds of choices still move it: spending, saving more (including the catch-up contributions), the retirement date or part-time work, and the Social Security claiming age. For our example couple, who reach 55 with $700,000 and face a shortfall of about $540,000 at 62 on the guardrails sketch, spending $10,000 a year less closed about $349,000, saving the amount of both catch-ups about $151,000, retiring at 64 instead of 62 about $424,000, three years of part-time work from 62 to 64 about $104,000, and claiming Social Security at 70 instead of 67 about $63,000. Spending $10,000 less and retiring at 64 together closed about $815,000, more than the whole shortfall. Those figures assume returns of 10% a year while working and 7% in retirement, before 3% inflation. The right order depends on the household.
What are the catch-up contribution limits for 2026 and 2027?
In 2026, savers 50 and older can add an $8,000 catch-up to the $24,500 base limit for a 401(k), 403(b), or governmental 457(b), or $11,250 for those who reach 60, 61, 62, or 63 during the year. IRAs allow a $1,100 catch-up on top of the $7,500 limit, and a health savings account allows an extra $1,000 from 55 for anyone eligible to contribute to one. A saver whose 2025 Social Security wages from the employer sponsoring the plan exceeded $150,000 must make the age-based catch-up to a 401(k), 403(b), or governmental 457(b) as a Roth contribution. For 2027, the workplace limits rise to $25,500, $8,500, and $11,750, the Roth line rises to $155,000 of 2026 wages, and the IRA limits stay the same.
How do I count Social Security when I check whether I’m on track?
Subtract the benefit you expect at your planned claiming age, in today’s dollars, from your retirement spending before you size the portfolio, and price any years between retiring and claiming separately. Your statement at ssa.gov shows the estimate at each age. For anyone born in 1960 or later, a benefit on your own work record pays 70% of the benefit at 67 if claimed at 62, and 124% if you wait to 70 (a spousal benefit is cut more at 62 and stops growing at 67), so the claiming age changes both the long-term gap and the length of the bridge. In our example, claiming at 70 instead of 67 lowered one couple’s number by about $63,000 on the guardrails sketch and about $222,000 for a plan that never adjusts, because the larger lifelong benefit outweighed the cost of three more bridge years.
Does the 4% rule tell me how much I need to have saved?
The 4% rule gives only a rough sketch: dividing the yearly gap your portfolio must cover by about 4% gives a starting point for a plan that never adjusts, not a plan. We lean toward pairing it with about 5.5% for a plan that will follow guardrails, and toward treating both as a conversation starter. The gap has to include the income tax on withdrawals and leave out the years before Social Security begins, which need their own reserve. In our example, a couple with a $43,000 long-term withdrawal sketched to $782,000 at 5.5% and $1,075,000 at 4%, before a bridge reserve of about $475,000.
