Financial Planning9 min read

Making Decisions: How to Think Clearly, Act Intentionally, and Live by Your Values

Jim Crider

Jim Crider, CFP®

November 6, 2025

What if the hardest part of making a good decision isn't the decision itself — but realizing there's a decision to be made?

Most people go through their days on autopilot. They respond to what's in front of them, take the default option, and move on. They're not lazy or unintelligent. They just haven't stopped to recognize that every action — even the ones that feel automatic — involves a choice.

If you want to live intentionally — with your money, your time, your career, your relationships — you need to understand how decisions actually work. Not in theory, but in practice. How your brain tricks you. Where your blind spots are. And how to build a process that leads to better outcomes, not just faster ones.

You're Making More Decisions Than You Think

Here's an example that might sound familiar. You're at a gathering. There's a bowl of chips on the table. You're not hungry. But you keep eating them — mindlessly, one after another — until someone takes the bowl away. And when they do, you say, “Thank you. I would have eaten that whole thing.”

Now scale that up. How many financial decisions, career decisions, and relationship decisions are you making the same way — not because you chose them, but because you never paused long enough to realize there was a choice? This is what it means to live reactively instead of intentionally.

The Framework: Values, Goals, Decisions, Actions

At Intentional Living Financial Planning, every client engagement follows a framework: Values → Goals → Decisions → Actions.

Values come first — what's truly important to you. Goals flow from those values. Decisions are the trade-offs you'll navigate along the way. And actions are what you actually do, day by day.

Most people skip to action. Some set goals first. Very few start with values. And almost nobody spends real time thinking about the decision layer — the place where trade-offs live, where opportunity costs hide, and where most financial mistakes are made.

Your Brain Is Working Against You (Here's How)

Decision-making research — from psychologists like Daniel Kahneman and strategists like Annie Duke — has revealed a long list of mental shortcuts and biases that quietly sabotage our choices.

Narrow framing.The tendency to see a decision as “this or that” instead of exploring a wider range of options. Someone might ask, “Should I buy this rental property or not?” when the better question is, “What's the best use of this capital given my goals, timeline, tax situation, and risk tolerance?”

Confirmation bias.We naturally seek out information that validates what we already believe. If you think a particular investment is a good idea, you'll find plenty of evidence to support it — and unconsciously dismiss the evidence that doesn't.

Overconfidence bias.Consider this: 90% of businesses fail within the first five years. Yet 95% of entrepreneurs believe they will succeed. That gap isn't just optimism — it's a systematic overestimation of our own knowledge and ability.

Availability and recency bias. We overweight events that are vivid or recent. After a market downturn, investors pull their money out at the worst possible time. Our brains are wired to treat recent, dramatic events as more likely than they actually are.

Illusion of control. We overestimate how much influence we have over outcomes. In financial planning, this shows up when people believe they can time the market, pick the right stocks, or predict what the economy will do next year.

Loss aversion.The pain of losing is roughly twice as intense as the pleasure of gaining. If someone offers you a coin flip — heads you win $100, tails you lose $100 — most people won't take it. This asymmetry shapes how we invest, how we spend, and how we evaluate risk.

The Planning Fallacy: Why Your Budget and Timeline Are Probably Wrong

One of the most practical biases to understand is the planning fallacy— our tendency to build plans around best-case scenarios while ignoring statistical norms.

Ask someone how much they spend per month, and they'll typically underestimate by about 35%. Ask a couple how long their home renovation will take, and they'll give you a number that's 30 to 40% too optimistic — on both time and cost.

The fix is straightforward: start with the statistical baseline, not your personal best case. If the average remodel of this type takes nine months, that's your anchor. Then adjust from there based on your specific circumstances.

Watch Out for the Gorilla

There's a famous psychology experiment where participants are asked to count basketball passes in a video. Midway through, a person in a gorilla suit walks across the screen and dances. Almost nobody notices.

This is exactly what happens when you're so focused on one aspect of a decision that you miss everything else. Good decision-making requires zooming out regularly. Not just asking, “Is this a good investment?” but asking, “How does this fit into the full picture of what we're building?”

Tools That Actually Help

The premortem. Before you commit to a plan, imagine it's a year from now and the plan has failed. Ask yourself: what went wrong? This forces you to confront risks and blind spots before they become problems.

Stop, Start, Continue.A simple review framework. What should you stop doing? What should you start? What's working and should continue? Applied to your finances, your business, or your weekly schedule, this creates a rhythm of intentional evaluation.

Seek wise counsel.Plans succeed with many advisors. Not yes-men who tell you what you want to hear, but people who will challenge your assumptions, point out your blind spots, and ask the questions you haven't thought of.

The Takeaway

You are not a victim of your circumstances. You are the product of your decisions — including the ones you didn't realize you were making.

The path to better outcomes isn't just about working harder or earning more. It's about deciding better. That means slowing down enough to recognize when a decision is being made, understanding the biases that cloud your judgment, and building a process that keeps your choices aligned with what actually matters to you.

You can have anything you want. But you can't have everything. The decisions you make — and the ones you avoid — determine which version of your life you end up with. Make them intentionally.

Listen to this episode

This article was inspired by Episode 6 of The Intentional Living Podcast.

Jim Crider

About the Author

Jim Crider, CFP®

Jim is a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER™ and founder of Intentional Living Financial Planning in New Braunfels, Texas. He helps individuals and families align their wealth with what matters most in life.

Ready to Align Your Money With What Matters?

Schedule a free 15-minute conversation to talk about your priorities and see if we're a good fit.